5 Coffee Myths I’m Not Buying
Updated: Oct 16

Some coffee myths are surprisingly expensive. Others simply make breakfast more complicated than it needs to be.
You don’t have to buy the priciest beans, build a laboratory on your kitchen counter or follow someone else’s perfect recipe to enjoy good coffee. Here are five coffee myths I’m not buying—and what I’d pay attention to instead.
1. The More Expensive the Coffee, the Better It Will Taste
This is probably the easiest myth to challenge. Expensive coffee can be fantastic, but it can also be completely wrong for your taste. Coffee is personal. One person might love a bright, fruity Ethiopian coffee, while someone else might prefer a darker, chocolatey Brazilian brew. Neither person is wrong.
Price can reflect factors like rarity, production costs, quality, processing, traceability, and how difficult a coffee is to produce. But it doesn't guarantee that you'll love the taste. The best coffee is simply the one you enjoy drinking—not the one with the most impressive price tag.
TRY THIS: Describe your preferred flavours to the roaster before choosing a bag. They will love to tell about all the different tasting notes, we certainly do.
2. Stronger Coffee Means More Caffeine
This one causes a lot of confusion. When people say a coffee is “strong,” they might mean it tastes intense, bitter, heavy, or concentrated. That doesn't necessarily mean it contains more caffeine.
Espresso is concentrated and often contains more caffeine per millilitre than filter coffee. But a large mug of filter coffee can contain more caffeine in total than a single espresso. The result depends on the beans, the amount of ground coffee, the brewing method and the serving size.
So a drink’s bitter or intense flavour isn’t a reliable caffeine guide. Your taste buds don’t come with a
built-in caffeine meter.
TRY THIS: Compare serving sizes and coffee doses, rather than bitterness.
3. Dark Roast Coffee Has More Caffeine
This misconception seems logical. Dark coffee looks stronger and tastes stronger. Therefore, it must contain more caffeine. Except it doesn't work that way.
Roasting changes the physical and chemical characteristics of the coffee, but the caffeine itself is relatively stable during normal roasting. Roast colour isn’t a reliable guide to caffeine. Roasting changes a bean’s weight, size and composition, so comparisons can differ depending on whether you measure your coffee by grams or by scoops. The coffee species, dose and brewing method matter too.
Choose a dark roast because you enjoy its flavour—not because you expect an automatic caffeine upgrade.
TRY THIS: Choose roast style for flavour; don’t use colour as a caffeine measure.
4. You Need Expensive Equipment to Make Good Coffee
This is one of the most costly misconceptions in coffee. You can spend thousands on a coffee setup, but you can also make a very good cup with a relatively inexpensive brewer. Good equipment can certainly make brewing easier, more consistent, or more enjoyable. A good grinder, for example, can make a noticeable difference.
However, expensive equipment can't rescue bad coffee, stale beans, or a completely unsuitable recipe. A simple brewer, decent grinder, fresh coffee, and a little attention can produce a fantastic cup. The equipment is there to help you make the coffee. It isn't supposed to be the coffee.
TRY THIS: Improve your recipe and consistency before replacing equipment. See our Brewing guides for more tips >
5. There Is One “Correct” Way to Make Coffee
This might be the biggest misconception of all. Coffee enthusiasts sometimes talk about recipes as though there is a single perfect combination of coffee, water, temperature, grind size, and brewing time. There isn't.
There are good starting points and recipes that work particularly well for certain coffees. There are techniques that make brewing more repeatable. But coffee changes. Beans age, and different coffees respond differently to water and temperature. Different grinders produce different results. And, perhaps most importantly, people like different things.
If your coffee tastes good to you, you're already doing something right. You don't have to brew it according to someone else's idea of perfection. The nice thing about coffee is that you can go as deep into all of this as you want. You can measure everything, weigh your water to the nearest gram, adjust your grinder by tiny increments, and spend half an hour discussing extraction. Or you can simply put some coffee in a French Press, pour in some hot water, and enjoy your breakfast. Both are allowed.
TRY THIS: Change one brewing variable at a time and keep what tastes better. Take time to discover what you enjoy. Try various origins and roasts. Visit local coffee shops to sample different brews. Engage with baristas and learn about their favorite coffees. This exploration can deepen your appreciation for coffee.
Learn more with How to read a coffee label
Coffee should be interesting. It shouldn't become homework!
— Henning Al-Gharb Coffee Roasters, Algarve
☕ Want to make better coffee at home?
Join The Friday Filter. One useful coffee tip every Friday from the Al-Gharb Coffee Roasters.
Brewing advice, coffee experiments, things we've learned from roasting—and occasionally things we've learned by getting it completely wrong.
No coffee snobbery. Just better coffee.











_edited_edited.png)


Comments